The Ortho Molecular Answer
Home | · | About | · | Credentials | · | History | · | FAQ | · | Testimonials | · | Contact |
What's New | · | Podcasts | · | Illnesses | · | Case Studies | · | Articles | · | Resources | · | Supplements |
Diabetes - The Importance of Injury as a Cause of Impaired Mitochondrial Oxidation in Diabetes
The Importance of Injury as a Cause of Impaired
Mitochondrial Oxidation in Diabetes
John P. Cleary, M.D.
Journal
of Orthomolecular Medicine Vol. 3, Number 4, 1988
Introduction
In diabetes, glucose metabolism via the Krebs cycle is
impaired, and this leads to reduced cellular energy and elevated blood sugar
levels. When a cell is damaged by oxidation injury, cytosol NAD levels fall and
ATP levels decrease, If the DNA strand breaks can be repaired, and the cell
regains lost NAD, the energy system can function again, but frequently cell
death ensues- Experimental diabetes is caused by this same mechanism, except
that a chemical alkylating agent is used to cause the DNA strand breaks in the
cell nuclei. DNA strand breaks activate the enzyme poly ADP-ribose synthetase
which cleaves NAD, and cause NAD levels in the cytosol to fall to zero.
Schaufstetter (1985) has shown that oxidation injury can act in the same manner
with the same resultant low NAD in the cytosol and low ATP
Antioxidant
Defenses Affect Energy Production
The recent work on oxidant injury to
cells, by Schaufstetter et al (1985), (1986), Spragg (1985), and Wohaieb (1987),
has provided us with insight into the potential cause of most cases of diabetes,
as well as many other diseases formerly classified as being of unknown etiology.
Superoxides and peroxides are produced by the mitochondria in the course of
normal oxidation of nutrient molecules. There is an antioxidant defense system
which consists of superoxide dismutase and catalase enzymes, ascorbic acid,
vitamin E, glutathione, beta carotene and the coenzymes NAD and NADP, that can
deal with oxygen radicals and prevent damage to the cell structures. When the
oxygen radicals are greater than the ability of the antioxidant system to
deactivate them, then there is oxidation injury.
Experimental oxidation
injury was induced by Schaufstetter in leukocytes with varying concentrations of
peroxide which acted as an oxidizing agent causing DNA strand breaks in the
nuclei. This caused activation of the enzyme poly(ADP-ribose) synthetase which
cleaves NAD, causing NAD and ATP levels to fall. Schaufstetter measured an 80%
fall in NAD levels in 20 minutes, in the cells, after a dose of peroxide was O.1
to 2.5mM- Mitochondrial oxidation is then stopped by the cytosol NAD levels
being reduced to zero- Repair of the DNA strand breaks proceeds while the cell
is functioning, but using an alternate energy pathway. Specialized cell
functions cease during this repair phase due to low ATP levels. If the repair is
completed properly the cell must acquire new NAD in the cytosol to return to the
mitochondrial oxidation which generates the majority of the ATP in eukaryotic
cells. If the NAD in the cytosol cannot be restored or if they are oxidation
damaged, the mitochondrial membranes are not repaired, the cell remains in a low
energy mode of function that prevents specialized cell function necessary for
normal organ function- Thus organ failure is the result of energy failure on a
cellular level, because of oxidation damage of the mitochondrial membranes
and/or low NAD- In the case of the beta cell in the pancreas this means that
proinsulin production ceases until NAD levels in the cytosol are restored.
Giving niacin, vitamin B3 provides a precursor for NAD
Robbins et al
(1980) found superoxide dismutase l05 ug administered 50 minutes prior to 45
mg/kg STZ prevented the diabetogenic effect that is seen when STZ alone is
given. Superoxide dismutase is an enzyme known to be part of the antioxidant
defense system of the cell, and a scavenger of free radicals, (Oberley 1986).
Robbins believes that the mechanism of action is the inactivation of free
radicals that are generated by STZ, before damage can be done to DNA- This would
prevent activation of poly (ADP-ribose) synthetase and inactivation of
mitochondria which prevents decline in ATP and cessation of insulin production
by the beta cells
Membrane Transport of Glucose and Sodium Impaired by
Low ATP
When the cell reaches low ATP levels, the sodium pump is impaired
(Greene 1987)- Boquist (1988) shows that when the Krebs cycle is inhibited, the
Mitochondria swell up. This has an adverse effect on the membrane transport of
glucose, because glucose and sodium are transported into the cell together. Then
the sodium ion must be pumped out via the NA+K+ ATPase or sodium pump. Sodium
transport requires ATP energy, thus membrane transport of glucose indirectly
uses ATP.
Early observations by S, Soskin and R. Levine, as discussed by
Lehninger (l975) showed that the peripheral tissue of diabetic animals are
deficient in removal of hexose, (a 6 carbon sugar) from the blood. This happened
when the animals were tested at normal blood sugar levels. If blood sugar is
raised to fi00 mgm% the hexose uptake by tissues is increased, This indicates
that the basic defect in diabetes is membrane transport of glucose into the
cell- M. B. Davidson (1986) discusses the pathogenesis of the type II Diabetes
Mellitus where there is often normal insulin levels or even an excess of insulin
and elevated blood sugar. Insulin deficiency is not the cause of type 2 diabetes
mellitus. Diabetes is primarily an impairment of membrane transport of glucose,
causing a deficiency of glucose inside the cell and an elevated level of glucose
outside the cell.
In a study done with Etomoxir (Sandoz) used with and
without Nicotinic Acid, FFA levels and triglyceride levels go up in rat plasma
when Nicotinic Acid is not included. When Etomoxir is used with Nicotinic Acid,
glucose levels go down, FFA levels go down and triglyceride levels go down- This
study, (Reaven 1988) shows that NAD is needed to reestablish the metabolism.
Insulin levels did not change during any stage of the experiment. Reaven's study
created an animal model of adult onset diabetes by using older adult rats and
low dose STZ treatment. They were able to lower blood sugar, FFA and
triglyceride levels to normal using boll) Nicotinic Acid and Etomoxir, four
hours after administering them both by gastric tube or injection SQ, However,
when Etomoxir was administered alone, the FFA and triglyceride levels both went
up considerably, although blood sugar levels went down to normal levels.
Nicotinic Acid administered alone caused the FFA levels to return to normal, and
triglyceride levels to normal, but blood sugar was still somewhat elevated. I
feel prolonged use would lower blood sugar to normal, as this has been my
experience with Nicotinic Acid, just lowering blood sugar will not cure diabetes
and elevated FFA levels and triglyceride levels, I believe, are symptoms of
impaired cell metabolism. In addition there is in the diabetic enhanced
gluconeogenesis, which is the formation of glucose in the liver from amino
acids
The body is metabolizing protein to make glucose. Most of this
glucose ends up excreted in the urine and leads to the wasting seen in
diabetics. At the same time there is an almost complete cessation of conversion
of glucose to fatty acids via acetyl-CoA. Normal animals convert about l/3 of
ingested carbohydrate to fat- The combination of excessive gluconeogenesis with
absent fatty acid formation leads to body wasting. Very little metabolism of
glucose for energy production occurs in the diabetic. What does occur is mostly
in the brain, which can use only glucose and in emergency the kettle body beta
hydroxybutarate can be used to make energy.
Elevated blood glucose is
therefore due to impaired membrane transport of glucose into cells and into the
mitochondria of the cells where it is metabolized into energy, Impaired
transport could lead to further deficient energy levels inside the cell. We know
that in artificially induced diabetes, cytosol NAD levels become zero preventing
normal metabolism by the oxidative pathways involving the citric acid cycle
inside the mitochondria. When alternate energy pathways are activated including
the hexose monophosphate shunt and fermentation,
of glucose to lactic acid.
These path. ways are located in the Cytosol Of the cell and do not use the
mitochondria. The hexose monophosphate shunt requires NADP as a coenzyme and
this substance is not split by the poly (ADP-ribose) synthetase
enzyme.
The Non-Obese Diabetic Mouse Model
Nakajima, H., and
Yamada, K., et al, have documented that when the NOD mice become spontaneously
diabetic they also develop antibodies to the beta cells ~1986). (Perhaps the
body does this in an effort to remove the damaged beta cells from the pancreas-)
These researchers also show that this antibody dependent cell-mediated
cytotoxicity can be stopped with nicotinamide (1986). Yamada, K., et al, had
previously shown (l982) that the nicotinamide inhibits the
poly-ADP-ribosylation, a reaction which depletes NAD levels, and which in the
beta cells can result in no insulin production and even beta cell
death
A Single Metabolic Defect is the Cause of All Complications Seen
in Diabetes
Dr. Albert Winegrad in the 1986 Banting Lecture on diabetes,
(Diabetes, Vol- 36, March 1986) attempts to show how a single mechanism, the
activated Polyol pathway, can cause all the complications seen in all types of
diabetes- His whole concept is that a defect in the metabolism leads to
activation of this abnormal metabolism, however the low NAD levels in diabetes
(Spies l939) allows a more complete explanation in regard to the Polyol pathway
defect, since the pathway depends upon an excess of NADPH being present. This
was demonstrated by the Russian researcher Obrosova, (l985) Nicotinamide given
in experimental STZ diabetes in rats corrected the sorbitol pathway defect. The
nicotinamide induced an increase in NAD+/NADH and NADP+/NADPH ratios which was
accompanied by a decrease in sorbitol formation. There was inhibition of the
aldose reductase which leads to sorbitol formation and an increase in the
sorbitol dehydrogenase reaction which metabolizes sorbitol to fructose. Yeh et
al (1987) also suggests that sorbinil does not correct the sodium pump defect in
diabetic rats by raising the myo-inositol.
It is however interesting to
follow the path to the sorbitol buildup. Excess hydrogen ion accumulates in the
cytosol causing NAD and NADP to be reduced to NADPH-H+ and NADH-H+. There would
be reduction in ATP production and a fall in pH in the available NAD or NADP.
This would keep NAD and NADP at low to non-existent levels, Energy production in
the cell then switches to the hexose monophosphate pathway which operates in the
cytosol and uses NADPH. I hypothesize that the excess NADPH also drives the
Aldose Reductase enzyme to make sorbitol, but does not go on to make fructose
because of the NAD deficiency. Sorbitol accumulates in the cells and serves as a
means of reducing the excess H+ ion,
Dr. Wingrad does not address the
problem of the impairment of NA+K+ATPase which leads to impaired glucose
transport. Glucose is transported with Na+ ion into the cell, then Na+ must be
transported back across the membrane by the sodium potassium ATPase. In a sense
the movement of Na+ provides the source of energy to move glucose and impairment
of sodium transport impairs glucose transport. Insulin alone does not correct
impaired membrane transport of glucose, as is seen in adult onset diabetes there
is often high or normal insulin levels and still elevated blood glucose from
impaired membrane transport of glucose.
NAD Deficiency is the Other
Half of the Story in Diabetes
Because insulin was discovered in l922 and
niacin in l937, no one realized the importance of NAD deficiency in diabetes,
even though a small group headed by Tom Spies in l939 published their study of
low NAD levels in diabetics. Controlling blood sugar will not prevent the
progress of the disease diabetes since it is really a subclinical form of
pellagra. Wahlberg (1985) showed that nicotinamide has a protective effect
against nephropathy in diabetic rats. If 20% of patients with type 1 diabetes of
more than 26 years duration do not develop clinical microangiopathy even though
their blood sugar may not have been optimal, it means that long term
complications in diabetes are not only related to high blood sugar
concentration, but also to other metabolic disturbances- When nicotinamide was
given to rats with STZ diabetes of 6 months duration there was a lowering of
blood sugar and a decrease in nephropathy as measured IgG immunofluorescent
staining of the glomeruli. They found a deficiency of oxidized pyridine
nucleotides (NAD+NADP+) which could account for the metabolic impairment of
diabetes,
These discoveries should lay to rest any attempts to use aldose
reductase inhibitors to block sorbitol synthesis- When a vitamin will correct
the metabolic defect, why resort to a drug which can only create more side
effects and complications? Any aldose reductase inhibitors now under development
must prove they are more effective than nicotinamide or nicotinic acid to
warrant their use
Spies, Sydenstricker (1939), Vilter (l939) found
diabetics to suffer from extremely low NAD levels. Early researchers such as
Evans (l939), Sutton (1940) and Spies (l939) had extensive experience with the
many subtle symptoms of pellagra. But a lapse of niacin research during and
after World War 11 gave the pharmaceutical companies a voice of unquestioned
authority over the new practicing clinicians who had no real experience with
niacin deficiency cases and had not lived through events of the Pellagra years
in the South, indeed did not recognize the symptoms of pellagra. I discuss this
disease in my recent publication on the NAD Deficiency Diseases, wherein I
describe the subclinical pellagras (Cleary 1986), and their response to the
administration of niacin
There was a further study of diabetes niacin
therapy done in England in l943 (Neuwahl) using niacinamide. Incipient cases of
diabetes could often be removed from insulin and could actually be cured of
diabetes, according to Neuwahl, and some long standing cases had improvement
with a lowering of the insulin requirement. Since niacin could not be patented
to make a large profit, I believe the then aggressive marketing of the
stilfonylurea compounds by the drug companies also tended to obscure the pursuit
of the true cause and treatment of diabetes.
A New Look at the
Problem
In 198 1 Japanese biochemists studying artificial diabetes in lab
animals using the alkylating agents alloxan and streptozotocin found that an
enzyme in the cell was activated by single strand breaks of DNA (Yamamoto 198l).
This enzyme, poly (ADP-ribose) synthetase split the NAD in the cytosol reducing
NAD cytosol to zero and thus inactivating the citric acid cycle energy
production of the mitochondria. Pancreatic beta cells, with no NAD and inactive
mitochondria stopped functioning, insulin was not produced, and the diabetic
condition induced. Further experiments by this group in Japan showed that
pretreating the rats with niacinamide, zinc, picolinic acid or benzamide before
giving the alkylating agent would prevent the development of diabetes. The
outcome depended on whether the pancreatic cells could repair the single strand
breaks in the DNA and then obtain new NAD resume insulin production, or whether,
the cells were seriously damaged or unable to build up cytosol NAD levels
necessary to resume function.
Spies (l939) found that diabetics in
ketoacidosis had NAD levels as low as pellagrins, and this leads to impairment
of the normal oxidative pathways like the Krebs cycle. In other words, they had
pellagra and this is the real cause of ketoacidosis.
How the Heart and Vascular Complications Result from the Impaired Cellular
Energy of Pellagra by Oxygen Injury
Accelerated atherosclerosis is a
facet of the diabetic disease progression; it changes the blood vessels of the
entire body, and combined with the impairments of the immune system, this
vascular restriction leads to tissue breakdown and gangrene. Jackson (l985)
estimates that 80% of diabetic deaths are from vascular disease secondary to the
abnormal metabolism found in diabetes.
Hypertension as a cause of some of
the pathology of diabetes is also demonstrated by Hommel et al (1986). They show
that acute reduction of arterial blood pressure reduces urinary albumin
excretion in type 1 diabetic patients with incipient nephropathy, They
demonstrate this same result in human insulin dependent diabetic, upon whom
Clonidine was used to reduce arterial blood pressure and there was a decrease in
urinary albumin excretion
Roberto Zarz, et al, in discussing the
prevention of diabetic glomerulophathy by pharmacological amelioration of
glomerular capillary hypertension (1986), also indicate this- Experimental
diabetes in rats demonstrate that kidney damage associated with diabetes can be
prevented by lowering blood pressure and especially glomerular capillary
pressure. Apparently in diabetes there is increased blood pressure to kidney
capillaries with increases in blood filtration in the glomerulus. This results
in loss of albumin in the urine and destruction of glomeruli. Blood pressure in
the rats in this study was lowered by angiotensin I converting enzyme inhibitor
called endaprin. Kidney damage is prevented by reducing glomerular hypertension.
The albuminuria was also prevented by lowering the glomerular pressure- When
niacin is given to hypertensives the blood pressure is gradually reduced, as in
my case number 2 discussed below, to normal, and the mechanism of action is
believed to involve the improved action of the sodium pump that results from
providing adequate ATP levels to the cells. This same mechanism would be
involved in correcting the hypertension of diabetics and thus preventing renal
damage and albuminuria
Myocardiopathy is Due to Low ATP
In
diabetic rats low ATP levels have been found in the myocardium (Jenkins et at
1986), (Jackson l985) and this could account for the myocardiopathy seen in
diabetes. The low ATP levels in cardiac tissue provides us with insight into the
basic problems in diabetes which is impaired energy production leading to organ
failure, including the heart, and death.
Nomikos et al (1986) conclude
that oxygen derived free radicals may be the cause of most diabetes, with a
reference to Okomoto's (l98l) model for beta cell damage having a common final
pathway for toxic agents such as streptozotocin, alloxan, and inflammatory
tissue damage. Oxygen injury in the beta cell would indeed muse cessation of
specialized cell function producing insulin deficiency. Simultaneous oxygen
injury to other cells such as the myocardium would produce the heart disease.
Oxidation damage is most severe in mitochondria because mitochondria oxidize the
majority of the nutrients, the membranes are therefore most likely to be
impaired because the superoxides and peroxides are formed there, leading to
peroxidation of the lipids of that mitochondria causing the cell to turn to
alternate energy pathways, such as the pentose shunt, as a means of continuing
energy production. Okomoto's model (198l, page 57) shows his concept of a final
common pathway for cell injury by alloxan and streptozotocin causing damage to
proinsulin synthesis in the beta cell. Additionally there is the superoxide as
another cause of free radical formation as per Schaufstetter (1986), vitamin C
and E and beta carotene as additional free radical scavengers; and the zinc ion
(ZN2+) as an additional inhibitor of the poly (ADP-ribose)
synthetase
Measures that also help restore cell energy production because
they are also free radical scavengers include Vitamin C in daily doses of 3 to
20 grams (Lehninger l975), Vitamin E in daily doses of 12001600 IU (Lehninger
l975), Linseed oil 30 to 60 mL daily, fish oil or cod liver oil, and beta
carotene and niacin 500 mg daily as a precursor to NAD. Although Okamoto used
niacinamide as a free radical scavenger and NAD precursor, there is an advantage
to using niacin instead which is that it doesn't inhibit the DNA repair process,
i.e. the poly (ADP-ribose) synthetase reaction. If you use niacinamide you may
stop the repair of the DNA strand breaks, by inhibiting the poly (ADP-ribose)
synthetase and this would cause abnormal DNA and therefore tumor formation
(Yamamoto 198l).
Mitochondrial type oxidation is the Krebs cycle, which
relies upon NAD to function. If the cell fails in mitochondrial oxidation and
declines to dependence upon the pentose phosphate shunt pathway, the result will
be an excessive fatty acid production at the expense of glycogen- Fatty acids
are the storage form for the pentose shunt and they tend to be overproduced when
mitochondria are impaired, at the same time the burning of these fatty acids is
also limited. Overproduction plus limited use leads to a massive accumulation of
fat in the blood, cells, arteries, liver, kidney, etc. Fatty degeneration of
tissues and arteriosclerosis is therefore caused by mitochondrial membrane
damage by oxygen, Alternately, a decrease in the use of the pentose shunt causes
a decrease in the fatty acid synthesis and an increase in glycogen as an energy
storage molecule
Smith reports (l98l) a case of severe
hypertriglyceridemia in an alcoholic with diabetes, The combination of insulin
therapy and nicotinic acid 1200 mg daily returned the triglyceride levels to
normal. Insulin alone could not do this and Smith demonstrates the effectiveness
of including nicotinic acid in diabetes therapy to correct defects not
influenced by insulin alone, Niacin releases insulin from the beta cells because
it returns them to functioning organs, it generates a coenzyme which restores
the mitochondrial Krebs cycle.
The importance of fat metabolism in
diabetes is shown by Kamada (1986) who found diabetics to have impaired membrane
fluidity due to deficient unsaturated fatty acids, This deficiency in the
linolenic l8:3 omega 5 essential fatty acid is the dietary deficiency commonly
found in our modern western diet according to Rudin (l981) which complicates the
diagnosis and evaluation of diabetes, the deficiency must be corrected also.
When sardine oil was given the membranes were restored to normal. O'Dea (l984)
found Australian aborigines who were suffering from diabetes on the Western diet
and lifestyle were cured by returning them to their old native lifestyle and
diet of fish, kangaroo meat, and vegetation, which included a high amount of
omega 3 EFA and niacin, not found in our modern western diet, Membrame fluidity
of damaged mitochondrial membranes can be restored by the essential fatty acids,
the cellular ATP production is improved, and the cell functions once again.
There is improved sodium pumping and improved membrane transport of the nutrient
molecules like glucose and amino acids that enter cells and the mitochondria by
co-transport with sodium ion. The energy for membrane transport of glucose and
amino acids comes from the ATP used to pump sodium back across the membrane in
exchange for potassium inside the allows active transport of glucose into the
cell by cotransport with sodium. In the cell with low ATP, sodium tends to
accumulate inside the cell, The cells are swollen and when niacin is given to
diabetics the most dramatic change noticed by patient and doctor alike is the
movement of fluid out of the body.
A Biochemical Model for Insulin
Resistance
Trishitta (1984) shows ATP inhibits insulin binding to cell
receptor sites- it provides a biochemical model to explain "insulin resistance".
This concept is applicable to both type I and II diabetes. In type I or insulin
dependent diabetes there is often a worsening of the clinical course with the
need to raise the amount of insulin injected. Sometimes even a large increase in
the amount causes little or no change in hyperglycemia. The reason is that low
ATP levels in the cells causes an increase in the need for insulin binding to
receptors- Ordinarily this results in an increase in cell membrane transport of
nutrient molecules like glucose, amino acids, and fat globules but if the
mitochondria of the cell are inactivated due to low NAD in the cytosol or
damaged membranes from oxidation injury, or nonfunctioning due to omega 3 EFA
deficiency, the increased insulin is not effective in raising ATP levels which
then decreases insulin requirement. Instead the body seems to require more and
more insulin as the ATP levels fall in the cells with impaired mitochondrial
oxidation
As Applied to Porphyria
Streptozotocin and alloxan
have been used extensively to induce experimental diabetes in animals. At one
time it was believed that they had action only on the beta cell of the pancreas,
but this is not true. The beta cell is just the most sensitive to these agents.
Other cells can also be alkylated in the same way with the same outcome;
decreased cytosol NAD, low ATP, and cessation of specialized cell function.
Porphyria can be induced by STZ, alloxan, and mycotoxins which alkylate
hepatocytes and induce the same reaction seen in the cured by returning them to
their old native lifestyle and diet of fish, and vegetation, which included a
high amount of omega 3 EFA and niacin, not found in our modern western diet.
Membrane fluidity of damaged mitochondrial membranes can be restored by the
essential fatty acids, the cellular ATP production is improved, and the cell
functions once again. There is improved sodium pumping and improved membrane
transport of the nutrient molecules like glucose and amino acids that enter
cells and the mitochondria by cotransport with sodium ion. The energy for
membrane transport of glucose and amino acids comes from the ATP used to pump
sodium back across the membrane in exchange for potassium inside the allows
active transport of glucose into the cell by cotransport with sodium. In the
cell with low ATP, sodium tends to accumulate inside the cell. The cells are
swollen and when niacin is given to diabetics the most dramatic change noticed
by patient and doctor alike is the movement of fluid out of the body.
Massive
production of porphyrins is the hepatocytes response to low ATP levels. Gadjos
(l969) used glucose to elevate ATP and cure porphyria in rats. Pinelli (1972)
reversed STZ-induced porphyria with nicotinic acid, Spies (1938, l938, 1939)
gave a single dose of niacin 500 mg orally to diabetic patients with porphynuria
and the porphynuria cleared for three days. So we have a model in the beta cell
for studying oxidation injury and the resultant organ failure, and the
restoration of function with vitamin B3 which we can apply to porphyria also-
Rather, we should probably say porphyria is a stage of diabetes, or the two are
a form of pellagra, or substrate pellagras Rudin (l987) discusses it, Sato
(l987) has used STZ to produce hypertension and diabetes in an animal model
which confirms our experience in humans that they are both caused by low
NAD.
The Case Reports
Case 1. Hypertension brought under control
with niacin
A fifty-four year old Negro man with diabetes, hypertension
and early heart failure, was on Tolinase 250 mg daily for diabetes, Lasix 40 mg
daily, Aldomet 250 mg qid, Apresaline 50 mg daily. The diabetes was well
corrected when measured by blood sugar levels. The patient however, had
developed early heart failure and less of control of the hypertension with the
blood pressure at 180/l2O with medication. He felt very lethargic and suffered
headaches- Niacin 750 mg P.O. daily was given in three doses of 250 mg. Within
six days his blood pressure was l40/9O and he felt much better- At four weeks
blood pressure was l20/86 and medication remained with Tolinase 250 mg, Lasix 40
mg daily, Aldomet 250 mg daily, and Apresaline 50 mg daily- At eight weeks he
had blood pressure 130/90 but he had also eliminated the Apresaline 50 mg daily.
The patient had a feeling of increasing well being, and began to walk several
miles each day.
Case 2. Diabetes and Gout.
A forty-seven year
old white man with hypertension who was taking four different drugs for his
hypertension, arthritis, and gout. He then was found to have elevated blood
sugar and could not accept the idea of going on five different medications so he
stopped taking all of them, by himself. A few days later he consulted me about
his condition, flatly stating he would not take the usual regime of
pharmaceuticals. I started him on niacin 500 mg daily. In addition he took
vitamin C, 1000 mg daily,
zinc 50 mg tab daily, as well as one multiple
vitamin daily. After four weeks a glucose tolerance test was done which measured
as normal. His hypertension was gone also- There was no evidence of gout or
arthritis and the patient seemed to feel more energetic and slept better than
before. Six months later he continued on just niacin 300 mg with normal blood
pressure and blood sugar, no gout or arthritis.
Case 3.
A
sixty-four year old white male with an earlier history of alcoholism and now
with adult onset diabetes, presenting with emphysema, insomnia, a pre-gangrenous
condition on his left middle toe, chronic productive cough and shortness of
breath, and edema with abdominal distention (his waist had increased seven
inches in size). He had been on Tolinase 250 mg per day for two years and
Theodur 600 mg per day for his emphysema for several years. His edema was at
this point life-threatening, his enlarged heart was failing- Although he had
been treated for hypertension in the past years, his blood pressure appeared
normal, because his heart was unable in heart failure to raise the blood
pressure. During that time that he was being treated with thiazides he developed
diabetes, and in as much as the thiazides do not cure the original problem, and
diabetes is but another step of the pellagra and omega 3 EFA deficiency that he
actually had, his pellagra was progressing to its terminal stages. A
pharmaceutical diuretic would have improved superficially his edema but niacin
is an effective diuretic and as my diagnosis was that of pellagra, I used niacin
very successfully on this patient. He had a pellagra type skin breakdown on his
elbows, not very significant alone, but also an unhealing blister on his hand,
an area exposed to the sunlight. He was irrational, his urine was noted to be
dark at times, both very significant pellagra symptoms- Also classical for
pellagra was his insomnia, he slept only a few hours each night- He was unable
to cat except for very small amounts, also indicative- I did not have to check
for low NAD levels, he had pellagra written all over him. I put him on 500 mg
niacin per day, 2000 mg vitamin C per day, and a multiple vitamin. He quit all
of his prior medicines and at first for three months took only the niacin- With
only the niacin his pregangrenous condition on his middle left toe cleared up in
a matter of days. The pressing problem of his edema improved slowly, the first
month he lost 10 pounds and three inches off his waist and the swelling in his
ankles was cured. The second month he lost another 10 pounds and two more inches
off his waist. At six months he takes no pharmaceutical medicines, only his
vitamins. His blood sugar is normal, he is eating well, he is rational, his
urine is not dark, he feels in excellent health,
Case 4.
A
sixty-two year old white man with a long history of gout and a recently
discovered diabetes based on a blood sugar of 1190 mg% and 540 mg%- He usually
took Butazolidin for his gout when it flared up but decided to experiment with
niacin. He was given 250 mg bid. In four days his gout pain was gone and never
returned, which was better than the results he had experienced with Butazolidin
treatment. He continued on niacin 500 mg daily for one month, then he began
testing his urine with a test tape and noted 0 sugar at 7:00 a.m. and 1+ sugar
two hours after meals. This was much better than anticipated based on the blood
sugar readings at onset of treatment. That he was improving was obvious to us
both. After six weeks of therapy he developed a visual disturbance, inability to
focus, which may have been due to decreases in internal pressure in the eye from
the diuretic effect of niacin. He had a 5 diopter change in his glasses and then
could see well again. At eight weeks the blood sugar fasting was l56 mg%. At ten
weeks the two hour postprandial blood sugar was 120 mg%. At sixteen weeks he had
a 95 mg% blood sugar, and the blood pressure was 118/78.
Discussion of
Case Studies
If diabetes results from low cell ATP, then attempts to
restore the energy production system should improve or cure diabetes. Complete
recovery depends on the number of viable beta cells left in the pancreas that
can be restored to insulin production, however the complications of diabetes may
be ameliorated by restoring normal energy production to the rest of the body
even though insulin must be given in addition.
My clinical trial was
limited to four cases of adult onset diabetes and of these, two were old cases
treated with oral antidiabetic agents- The reason antidiabetic agents work is
that they mimic the action of NAD which is very low in diabetes, causing a
release of insulin from the beta cells, but they do not restore function of the
mitochondrial Krebs cycle as NAD does, they do not cure this problem. Two of the
cases were newly discovered cases not yet treated. All four cases responded to
therapy with nicotinic acid (vitamin B3), The old cases stopped taking their
oral agent, and the new cases took no pharmaceutical drugs, only vitamin
supplements. Blood sugar levels return to normal and the patients all
experienced a water diuresis over a period of several months that resulted in a
loss of 20 to 30 pounds. Nicotinic acid was given in oral doses of 500 mg day
for the first month to attempt to restore depleted NAD levels in the cells. It
takes 3 or 4 weeks on the 500 mg a day level to do this, and this is the same
dose used to treat pellagra, the known NAD deficiency disease. After a month,
250 mg per day is given long term- If the antioxidant system of the body could
be totally repaired, it is possible that niacin supplements would not be
necessary long term, but persons with diabetes have a lot of oxidation damage
that causes a higher niacin intake to be required to prevent
relapses.
Infants born to diabetic mothers have long been known to suffer a
higher than normal perinatal mortality rate They are usually heavier than normal
as a result of fluid accumulation due to defective membrane transport of sodium
and glucose. These infants could be quickly restored to normal metabolism by
giving them nicotinic acid and raising the depleted NAD levels of their
cells
Biochemical abnormalities of diabetes include excessive ketone body
formation with ketonuria and acidosis or excessive H+ ion accumulation- When
normal metabolic pathways of the citric acid cycle are disrupted, the oxidation
of hydrogen ion and the combining with oxygen in the cytochrome system of the
mitochondria is defective. Niacin corrects this.
Why are the eyes of a
diabetic more susceptible to vascular damage? We know that the retina uses only
fermentation of glucose to lactate to obtain energy. Is lactate concentration
more elevated in the retinal vessels of a diabetic? Are the cell membranes of a
diabetic damaged also by excess H+ ions? Membrane "fluidity" is dependent upon
maintaining unsaturated fatty acids in the membranes. Excess H+ ion seen in
diabetic acidosis may combine with unsaturated fatty acids to make them more
saturated and less fluid. Less fluid membranes are not able to be effective in
membrane transport. Since diabetes is the leading cause of blindness, treatment
with nicotinic acid and the omega 3 fatty acids may reverse the abnormal
metabolism and prevent blindness in diabetes